|
|
|
|
Valerie Putman: My Ugly Side
Truth be told, I’d like to write about the game that I’ve been playing for the last eight months. I’d like to write about the game that has constantly occupied my mind for the last month. I’d like to write about the game that I am working on non-stop this weekend to make sure that it is ready for the Gathering. But it’s a prototype and I can’t. I’ll just say that I am developing a game for Rio Grande Games from a new designer and I like it very much. So what can I write about this week? How about if I own up to the ugly side that games can bring out in me.
My defensive side: I’ve often been on the playtesting side of prototype development and I understand that my opinion may or may not have any impact. As the developer, I have a little more control. Once I make my mind up about something, I can get a little defensive. In fact, today it was brought to my attention that I was being downright snippy. Hmph.
My cranky side: Sometimes when occupied with playtesting or convention gaming, I can forget to sleep and eat regularly. When I get tired or hungry I can get really cranky and I am sure I have taken it out on my fellow gamers a few times. This category used to include caffeine withdrawal as well, but I recently gave up my 12-pack a day habit and I haven’t had a Diet Pepsi in nearly two weeks.
My competitive side: There was a recent thread in the Women and Gaming forum on BoardGameGeek about gamers who play for the experience vs. gamers who play to win. (The author was wondering if women are more likely to fall in the first category if they are gamers.) I think it is a silly distinction. If you’re not trying to win the game, are you actually following the rules and playing the game? Or are you just pretending the meeples are having a tea party and deciding what they’ll wear to prom? Okay, so maybe I am a little competitve. Most of the time I can turn it off and play to win without caring if I win. But a few years ago I attended my one and only World Boardgaming Championships and I am embarassed to say that my ugliest side of all came out. While I don’t remember the exact details of what happened, I was informed later that I had said something to make a little girl cry. Ugh.
My scrooge-y side: I hate prize tables. I am not a collector and I would be happy buying only five or six games a year – the ones that I rank at least an 8 and I would be devastated if it went out of print and I moved away to a part of the country without a big game club library and no one I knew had a copy so I could never play it. Well, I have to buy five or six games a year for the prize tables I participate in so the end result is that I add about five or six games to my collection each year but they aren’t my favorites of the year; they are whatever I ended up with from the prize tables.
Okay, now I’m just starting to sound cranky. It must be time for dinner or bed. (Or another round of edits on a set of rules that I want to get just right.)
I’ll be reporting live next week from the Gathering!!!
I’d rather be gaming,
Valerie Putman
Comments:
You must register with BGN in order to comment. Registration is free, but if you appreciate the news, previews, reviews and other material posted on Boardgame News, please consider becoming a member to keep the info flowing to your screen!|
I certainly noticed your desire to win on the one occasion that I participated......
Posted by Bruce Spears on Mar 30, 2008 at 03:17 AM | #
|
|
I think one of the unspoken rules of the adult boardgaming culture, at least the circles I run in, is a certain expected attitude about winning: You’re supposed to try to win, but once the game is over you’re not supposed to dwell on who one or acknowledge that winning or losing made you happy or sad. All in all I think it is a good cultural norm that a) keeps our worse natures in check and b) actually reflects our emotional investment in winning or losing MOST of the time. But I think it’d be nice to be more honest with ourselves and with each other and admit that SOMETIMES, winning matters quite a lot to us. Certain games, certain playings mean more to us than others. I think if we can stay on our best behavior (i.e. not making little girls cry), it’s okay to embrace those feelings. Posted by Jay Bloodworth on Mar 30, 2008 at 07:49 AM | #
|
|
Valerie, you’re not required to take anything home from a prize table. One guy in my former game group regularly donated a dozen games to the game giveaway at Unity Games (now a charity game auction), yet never entered to win any games himself. One game that continually brought out the worst in me was Magic the Gathering. I attended prerelease tournaments and pick-up booster draft games for a few years, and since I didn’t play often, I found myself making mistakes that wouldn’t appear if I played more regularly. At night I would replay these games in my mind over and over again. “Why didn’t cast that card first? How could I have tapped those lands instead of these? Etc.” The games were rarely fun because the opponents tended to be focused on nothing more than destroying you, and I took all that competition internally. Eric Posted by W. Eric Martin on Mar 30, 2008 at 10:17 AM | #
|
|
Okay, now you’re bringing out part of MY ugly side, namely curiousity and (game) lust. Prototype? For RGG?? And you’re the developer??? That sounds very cool. I never need an excuse you enjoy your company at the Gathering, but now I’m sure to seek you out, to see the fruits of your labors. Posted by Larry Levy on Mar 30, 2008 at 11:24 AM | #
|
|
Give us a hint. Does it rhyme with Beagles Blunder? :-) Posted by Peter Stein on Mar 30, 2008 at 12:26 PM | #
|
|
Mr. Stein - Negative.
But, if you’ve been to CABS anytime in the last three months, you’ve likely seen it at least once! Dale Posted by Dale Yu on Mar 30, 2008 at 06:30 PM | #
|
|
Larry, I’ll also have a copy of said prototype with me at the GoF, and I’ll be a bit easier to find as I’ll not be working during the day!
Dale
Posted by Dale Yu on Mar 30, 2008 at 07:07 PM | #
|
|
Larry, you didn’t get a chance to play game X. You REALLY want to play game X. I have considered my bad side, and I am NEVER comfortable at a convention. So I’m always a wee bit ill at ease. I don’t think I’ve ever made a little girl cry, though. I think I threw a game piece at Mark Jackson once, however. Everest was involved, so it was perhaps justified. But...ten minutes later my nose began to suddenly gush blood. Makes you wonder what kind of connections Mark has. Posted by Frank Branham on Mar 30, 2008 at 10:13 PM | #
|
|
Frank, not that I’m a little girl, and not that I cried - but you didn’t look very happy with me as we first met (and i ruined your game of Polarity). BTW, look forward to getting in a few (well, ten or more) games of “Game X” next week. Dale Posted by Dale Yu on Mar 30, 2008 at 11:21 PM | #
|
|
I wouldn’t dwell too much on it. Keep in mind that you dwell with a crowd that turns Elfenland into an hour-and-a-half epic saga. We all take gaming (too?) seriously. It is our blessing and our curse. There are times when it brings out parts of us that do not represent the better angels of our nature. But if we’ve spent any amount of time at all getting to know each other, than we know who each other is underneath the surface. That can smooth over a lot of rough edges that come out in competition. :) Posted by Stephen Schaefer on Mar 31, 2008 at 11:37 AM | #
|
|
I think I speak for the entire site when I say none of us wants to know what’s underneath Dale’s surface! Posted by Larry Levy on Mar 31, 2008 at 11:51 AM | #
|
|
Hmmm. Let’s just hope that “Game X” has some cross appeal to a “mass” audience. That’s ALL I ever hope for out of this. And that it plays six. : ) Cheers and wish you all the best for The Gathering. Ryan B. Posted by Ryan Bretsch on Mar 31, 2008 at 06:54 PM | #
|
|
Sorry Ryan. 2 to 4. But it should have mass appeal.
Posted by Dale Yu on Mar 31, 2008 at 06:58 PM | #
|
|
Oh well. Thanks for the update Dale. Speaking of playing six… for the first time, I DID get to play “Lifeboats” this weekend… with 7. (Two people shared as one player.) While still not quite as good as “I’m the Boss”, this was great as a change of pace to that game. And Lifeboats is a REAL fun game overall. Someone (of the female persuasion) actually called me a “BRAT” (LOL) I guess we’ll chalk that one up to the “cranky” side. And I didn’t even win. ; ) Posted by Ryan Bretsch on Mar 31, 2008 at 07:18 PM | #
|
|
"Well, I think it will appeal to Levy (and he’s got a fair bit of mass, that one)” True, dat. Guess that means the world revolves around ME! :-) Larry, hoping to discover some X appeal next week Posted by Larry Levy on Mar 31, 2008 at 08:53 PM | #
|
|
So Valerie, is it really too terrible to simply keep the games you receive from the prize table in shrink wrap and take them to the next con’s prize table, or does curiosity get the better of you after all? Posted by Jeff Allers on Apr 1, 2008 at 12:52 PM | #
|
|
Since when is there anything remotely wrong with being cranky? Jeez. Hey Pete Stein, can you help me get invited to the Gathering? I hear you have lots of pull.... Posted by Josh Adelson on Apr 1, 2008 at 11:31 PM | #
|
Next entry: Eco's The Name of the Rose – Coming from Ravensburger
Previous entry: Game Review: Key Harvest
































